Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower Review: The Ultimate Eco-Friendly Solution for Small Lawns?

We’ve all been there: it’s a beautiful Saturday morning, the sun is just beginning to crest over the fence, and you’re ready to tackle the yard. You pull the cord on your gas mower. Nothing. You pull again. A sputter, a cloud of blue smoke, and then silence. Not only are you battling a stubborn engine, but you’re also about to wake up every neighbor within a three-block radius. For those of us with smaller suburban plots or townhome patches, the traditional gas-guzzling mower often feels like bringing a sledgehammer to a thumb-tack fight. It’s heavy, it’s smelly, and it requires a constant cycle of oil changes and trips to the gas station. We wanted a simpler way to maintain our green space—something that felt more like gardening and less like industrial labor. That search led us directly to the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower, a tool that promises a return to basics without sacrificing the quality of your turf.

No products found.

What to Consider Before Buying a Manual Reel Lawn Mower

A Lawn Mowers & Tractors is more than just an item; it’s a key solution for maintaining the health and aesthetics of your outdoor sanctuary. While many homeowners reflexively reach for power tools, the manual reel mower represents a specific philosophy of lawn care. It solves the problem of noise pollution, eliminates the carbon footprint of your yard work, and, perhaps most importantly, provides a superior cut for the grass itself. Unlike rotary mowers that hack at grass blades with high-speed impact, a reel mower uses a scissor-like action that preserves the plant’s integrity, reducing the risk of disease and browning. If you are looking for a way to turn a chore into a low-impact workout while keeping your lawn looking like a golf course, this is the category to explore.

The ideal customer for this type of product is someone facing the challenges of a small-to-medium-sized yard (typically under 3,000 square feet) or someone who lives in a noise-sensitive community. It is also a perfect fit for the eco-conscious homeowner or those who, like us, simply hate the maintenance associated with internal combustion engines. However, it might not be suitable for those who have massive acreage, extremely steep hills, or a tendency to let their grass grow six inches tall before they decide to mow. If your yard is more “meadow” than “manicured lawn,” or if you have physical limitations that make pushing a 20-pound machine difficult, you might want to consider a self-propelled electric alternative.

Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:

• Dimensions & Space: Consider both the cutting width and the storage footprint. A 14-inch mower like the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower is exceptionally nimble, allowing you to navigate tight corners and narrow paths between flower beds where larger mowers would struggle. Furthermore, its compact nature means it can hang on a garage wall or tuck into a small shed without dominating the floor space.
• Capacity/Performance: Look at the number of blades and the height adjustment range. A 5-blade system is the “gold standard” for residential reel mowers, providing enough contact points to ensure a clean cut on most common grass types. The ability to adjust height—in this case from 0.5″ to 1.75″—is vital for adapting to different seasons and grass species.
• Materials & Durability: Not all steel is created equal. You want heat-treated alloy steel blades that can maintain their “edge” through multiple seasons. Cheaper, untreated metals will dull quickly, leading to “tearing” rather than “cutting,” which defeats the purpose of using a reel mower in the first place.
• Ease of Use & Maintenance: While manual mowers are “low maintenance,” they aren’t “no maintenance.” You should look for models that offer tool-less assembly and easy-to-grip handles. Over the long term, you’ll want a machine where the blades can be back-lapped or adjusted with simple tools to ensure the reel-to-bedknife contact remains perfect.

Transitioning from a power mower to a manual one is a lifestyle shift, and choosing the right model ensures that shift is a positive one. While the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower is an excellent choice for many, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:

No products found.

First Impressions: Unboxing the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

When the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower arrived, the first thing that struck us was the weight—or rather, the lack of it. At just over 9 pounds, the box felt surprisingly light. Unboxing was a straightforward affair; there were no complex engine components or bags of specialized oil to worry about. The “Great States Red” is a classic, vibrant hue that gives the machine a vintage, high-quality feel. Assembly was a breath of fresh air; we were able to see its full feature set and user reviews online before purchasing, but experiencing the tool-less assembly firsthand was even better. Within five minutes, the T-style handle was attached, and the mower was ready for the turf. It feels sturdy, with the alloy steel blades providing a reassuring weight to the reel mechanism itself, contrasting nicely with the lightweight composite wheels.

A Deep Dive into the Performance of the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

Setup and Ergonomics: The 5-Minute Transformation

One of the most daunting aspects of new outdoor power equipment is the assembly. We’ve all spent hours squinting at grainy diagrams and hunting for a 10mm wrench. The Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower completely eliminates this frustration. The assembly is advertised as tool-less, and in our experience, this is 100% accurate. The handle sections slide together and are secured with wing nuts that you can tighten by hand. We found that even someone with limited mechanical inclination could have this mower rolling in less time than it takes to brew a pot of coffee. One small tip we discovered: if the rubber handle grips feel a bit tight during installation, a tiny drop of soapy water makes them slide right on.

Once assembled, the ergonomics of the T-handle design really shine. The cushioned grip is comfortable, providing enough “give” to prevent hand fatigue during longer sessions. Because the mower is so light (9.3 lbs), the effort required to push it is minimal on level ground. We noticed that the 8.5-inch composite wheels provide excellent traction without digging into the turf. Whether you’re navigating a tight corner around a birdbath or mowing a straight line along a fence, the mower feels like an extension of your arms rather than a heavy piece of machinery you’re fighting against. This ease of use is a recurring theme in user feedback, with many noting that even those who previously struggled with heavy gas mowers find this a feature that really sets it apart.

The Cutting Action: Scissor Precision vs. Rotary Tearing

The heart of the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower is the 5-blade ball-bearing reel. To understand why this matters, you have to look at the physics of the cut. A standard gas mower uses a single blade spinning at high speeds to “whack” the grass. This often leaves the tips of the grass frayed and brown. The Great States mower, however, uses a scissor action. As the reel turns, the five blades pass against a stationary bedknife, snipping the grass cleanly. We found that the resulting look of the lawn is noticeably different—it looks more “polished” and uniform, almost like a carpet. This is the same technology used on professional golf greens, and having it in a residential 14-inch format is a game-changer for lawn enthusiasts.

In our testing, the “swooshing” sound of the blades is incredibly satisfying. It’s a rhythmic, mechanical sound that isn’t loud enough to drown out a conversation or a podcast. However, there is a caveat: this precision requires the grass to be at a manageable height. If you let your lawn turn into a hayfield, the reel will simply push the tall blades over rather than cutting them. We confirmed this with several user reports; while it handles “little trees” and standard weeds surprisingly well, tall, wispy dandelions can sometimes dodge the blades. For the best results, we found that mowing twice a week during the peak growing season keeps the grass at the perfect height for the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower to perform its best, often eliminating the need for raking clippings entirely as they are finely mulched back into the soil.

Maneuverability and Versatility in Small Spaces

If you have a yard with lots of “obstacles”—trees, flower beds, decorative stones, or narrow side-yards—the 14-inch width of this mower is actually a massive advantage. While a 21-inch gas mower might finish a wide-open lawn faster, it becomes a liability in tight spaces. We found that we could navigate the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower into areas where we previously had to use a string trimmer. This saves time and provides a much more even finish than a trimmer ever could. The lightweight design also makes it easy to “lift and pivot” the mower at the end of a row, which is far less taxing on the back than manhandling a 60-pound electric or 90-pound gas unit.

We also evaluated the height adjustment system. By moving the pins on the wheel assembly, you can choose between three positions ranging from 0.5″ to 1.75″. While this range is lower than some heavy-duty mowers, it is perfect for those who prefer a “low and tight” look. We found that the middle setting is the “sweet spot” for most suburban grasses like Kentucky Bluegrass or Fescue. For those who are checking the latest price and availability, it’s worth noting that the simplicity of this adjustment means there are fewer parts to break over time. It’s a mechanical, “set it and forget it” system that adds to the overall durability of the machine.

Long-Term Durability and the “Maintenance-Free” Promise

“Maintenance-free” is a bold claim, but the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower comes very close to fulfilling it. Because there are no spark plugs, air filters, or carburetors, the only thing that really requires attention is the blades. The heat-treated alloy steel is designed to stay sharp for years. We were particularly impressed by one user who reported that after seven years of use—and even being left outside in the elements for a portion of that time—the mower still cut perfectly with just a minor adjustment to the blade tension. This speaks volumes about the build quality of the reel mechanism.

To keep the mower in top shape, we recommend a simple “wipe down” after use to remove moisture and grass juice, which can be acidic. A quick spray of a light lubricant (like WD-40 or a silicone spray) on the reel bearings once or twice a season is all it takes to keep the action smooth. Unlike power mowers that have a finite lifespan dictated by the engine’s health, a well-cared-for reel mower can literally last for decades. When you consider the value proposition of this mower, the long-term savings on fuel, parts, and professional sharpening become very clear. It’s an investment in a tool that won’t let you down when you need it most.

What Other Users Are Saying

The general consensus among owners of the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower is one of pleasant surprise and genuine satisfaction. Many users admit they were initially hesitant to move away from power mowers but were quickly won over by the “satisfying swooshing noise” and the ease of use. One user, who travels full-time in a camper, noted that the lightweight design and lack of gas/oil storage make it the “perfect fit” for their lifestyle. This sentiment is echoed by many who live in urban environments with limited storage space. We also found several reviews highlighting the durability, with one long-term owner mentioning that even after seven years and some weathering, the mower still “cuts perfectly” without the blades ever being sharpened.

On the flip side, some users pointed out the inherent limitations of a 14-inch manual mower. A common critique is that it struggles with very tall or thick grass, requiring multiple passes or a “vacuum-like” motion to get every blade. One reviewer mentioned that if your lawn is larger than 300-800 square feet, the 14-inch width might feel too small, suggesting a larger model for bigger plots. Another user warned that long grass can occasionally get tangled in the wheels, emphasizing the importance of regular maintenance mows. Overall, the feedback suggests that as long as you understand the tool’s intended use—small, frequently maintained lawns—it is an exceptional performer.

Comparing the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower to its Top Alternatives

While the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower is a fantastic manual option, your specific lawn needs might require a different approach. Whether you need more power, a wider cut, or specialized lawn health tools, here is how it compares to three popular alternatives.

1. TIECTOWN 16-Inch Electric Dethatcher & Scarifier

No products found.

The TIECTOWN 16-Inch Electric Dethatcher & Scarifier is not a direct replacement for a mower, but rather a vital companion for those serious about lawn health. While the Great States mower provides a clean cut, the TIECTOWN unit focuses on removing the “thatch” (dead grass and debris) that can suffocate your lawn’s roots. If you find that your lawn looks brown despite regular mowing, it might be time for a dethatcher. We recommend this alternative for homeowners who already have a mower but want to take their turf to the next level. It’s corded, so you’ll need an extension lead, but the 15.5A motor makes quick work of clearing out debris that a manual mower simply can’t touch.

2. Greenworks 60V Self-Propelled Lawn Mower Battery Kit

No products found.

If you love the idea of “no gas and no oil” but your yard is too large or hilly for a manual push mower, the Greenworks 60V Self-Propelled Lawn Mower is the ultimate upgrade. Unlike the 14-inch Great States model, this is a 21-inch powerhouse that can handle up to 3/4 of an acre. The self-propelled drive system is a lifesaver on slopes, and the brushless motor provides power comparable to a gas engine without the noise or fumes. We recommend this for users who have a larger suburban lot and want the convenience of a battery-powered system that does the heavy lifting for them. It’s a significantly larger investment, but for the right yard, it’s worth every penny.

3. Greenworks 48V 17in Push Lawn Mower Kit

No products found.

The Greenworks 48V 17in Push Lawn Mower serves as a middle ground between the manual Great States and the heavy-duty 60V self-propelled models. It is still a “push” mower, meaning you provide the forward motion, but the dual 24V batteries power a rotary blade that can handle taller grass and tougher weeds much more effectively than a reel mower. With a 17-inch cutting deck, it’s slightly wider than our main subject, making it better suited for medium-sized residential yards. We recommend this for the user who wants an easy, lightweight electric experience but doesn’t want to be “punished” with extra work if they skip a week of mowing.

The Final Verdict: Is the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower Right for You?

After our extensive evaluation, we can confidently say that the Great States 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower is one of the best values in the lawn care world today—provided you use it for its intended purpose. It is a masterpiece of simplicity. It eliminates the noise, the smell, the cost, and the mechanical headaches of traditional mowing, replacing them with a peaceful, rhythmic experience that actually improves the health of your grass. Its lightweight nature and tool-less assembly make it accessible to almost everyone, from young adults in their first homes to seniors looking for a lighter way to maintain their yards. While it won’t replace a tractor for a five-acre farm, for the suburban dweller with a modest patch of green, it is nearly perfect.

If you are tired of fighting with pull-cords and want a lawn that looks like it was trimmed with a pair of professional shears, this is the tool you’ve been looking for. It’s durable, eco-friendly, and surprisingly fun to use. We highly recommend this mower for small yards, townhomes, and anyone who appreciates the “zen” of manual labor. Don’t let your lawn care be a source of stress any longer; take the leap into a quieter, greener way of living. You can check the current price and see more user success stories here to decide if it’s the right fit for your home today!